Seller Notes: Punished for Dropshipping Their Own Product

Seller Notes #3: The Dropshipper Who Wasn’t Dropshipping

Flagged for dropshipping, despite shipping their own product.

Amazon Seller Appeals and Amazon Seller Stories

A footwear seller’s sales plunged after losing shipping privileges. Promotional inserts inside the boxes complicated his effort to get them back.

When a retail seller named Alex went to dispute an unexpected dropshipping violation from Amazon, he had a fairly obvious explanation: the shoes he sold weren’t dropshipped at all. They shipped directly from his own warehouse. To the seller, the violation was an obvious misunderstanding and a quick appeal explaining the facts should have been enough to resolve the issue.
When the violation was issued, it imposed a restriction that removed the business’s merchant-fulfilled selling privileges and prevented him from shipping Amazon orders directly to customers. That meant a critical disruption to an operation that had generated nearly $800,000 in annual Amazon sales.

But a small detail complicated Alex’s rebuttal: some of his shoe boxes contained promotional inserts that identified another seller. Shipping from Alex’s own warehouse addressed one question, but what customers found inside their purchases raised another.

By the time Riverbend was pulled in to help with the situation in March 2026, the financial consequences were already substantial. The business had been averaging approximately $66,300 a month in sales prior to the restriction. But during the period when the restriction was active, sales averaged only $549 a month

Not just a business interruption — a 99% drop.

Alex submitted multiple appeals, all detailing the same argument: the products were his, from his warehouse, and were being shipped by his company to customers. But it wasn’t the where that Amazon was having issues with; it was the who. Because the inserts inside the product shipments identified an entirely different business, customers could easily be confused by the discrepancy and be unable to identify who was the real seller.

The available account of the case doesn’t explain what exactly triggered Amazon’s initial decision, or how the marketing slips within the boxes came to be flagged. But it does clarify why a simple denial of dropshipping left an important complication unresolved.

So while Alex’s appeals were factually accurate and did technically address the dropshipping claim, they didn’t answer the inconsistency at the heart of the violation.

Despite appeals and executive escalations, the restriction remained.

For Alex, each unsuccessful submission extended the negative impact on his sales. Explaining the past had not restored permission to operate as before. By May, the Riverbend expert handling the case, James, recommended trying a different approach..

The new plan would require Alex to concentrate on Fulfillment by Amazon, or FBA, through which Amazon handles order fulfillment, and build a record of compliant sales before seeking restoration of merchant-fulfilled privileges again.

That recommendation would require time and for Alex to keep operating under the restriction while assembling evidence for another appeal. This strategy certainly came with risk: there was no established date when Amazon would reconsider, and no assurance that a new selling record would change the outcome. But with repeated submissions being denied, there weren’t many other options left to try.

In October, Alex returned with nearly 1,000 FBA orders and a clean report with no new operational issues. The seller now had something that had been missing from the earlier appeal campaign: a substantial record of more recent activity to put before Amazon. James prepared another appeal, and Alex placed the submission on November 10.

A successful appeal means privileges are restored.

Three days later, Alex reported back to the Riverbend team that the appeal had succeeded and his merchant-fulfilled selling privileges had been restored.

The outcome never established that Amazon accepted every part of Alex’s original explanation, or which element of the renewed submission swayed the final decision. But the sequence of the case’s events do outline a fairly common appeal process: initial appeals failed; the seller built a new operating record; a later appeal succeeded.

That process highlights the value and impact of Riverbend’s role. James helped the seller pursue a different approach after the original effort didn’t deliver a result. Alex then spent months doing the operational work that gave the next submission a different foundation.

It’s also important to specify that, in this instance, reinstatement wasn’t the same as financial recovery. Our team won’t know if sales returned to their pre-restriction level, and there’s no evidence that the disruption’s losses were ever recovered.

But the successful appeal on November 13 meant Alex’s business could finally resume standard operations and fulfill Amazon orders directly. With an appeal behind him, rebuilding the business would come next.

One of the most rewarding parts of my job is helping ecommerce sellers protect the businesses they spent years building. Seller Notes shares some of those experiences, along with the practical lessons other sellers can learn from them. This is the second story in that series.

Author:

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
post
Newsletter
Protect My Account Now
Call our Seller Hotline: 877-289-1017

We Help Amazon and Walmart Sellers – Not Buyers.

NEW: Proactive Seller Account Protection! Join GUARDIAN Today!

Get My Free Case Review